Princes House Ltd v Distinctive Clubs

February 17, 2011
<p> The claimant landlord claimed five instalments on account of service charges from their defendant tenant. The tenant counterclaimed, contending that the landlord had failed to carry out roof repairs at the relevant time. The service charges arose from remedial works to the roof. The landlord had covenanted to use all reasonable endeavours to repair and replace the roof and, in addition, the lease provided a cap on the tenant’s liability for service charges up to December 2003. The landlord had notified the tenant of the intention to do the remedial works, but had postponed them until after the capping period expired. <br><br> The High Court held that the landlord had not used all reasonable endeavours to repair the roof and that the works should have been completed by the end of December 2003, such that the tenant would have had the benefit of the capping clause. If the work had been done when required, then the tenant would not have had to pay the sums claimed. <br><br> Analysis <br> This is an interesting case with potentially wide implications. If a landlord has a discretion about when to undertake works, is he required to do so at a time most convenient (and cost-effective) for the tenant? Would this logic be equally applicable to right-to-buy leases and s.125 notices? Or, is it the case that this argument was only available because of the specific covenant to use “all reasonable endeavours”? Sadly, the case was argued and reasoned very much from first principles, rather than on the basis of previous decisions and established case law. It remains to be seen what, if anything, inventive claimants can do with this decision. </p>
Subscribe to see more
Standard
  • 1 print copy of bi-monthly magazine

  • Access to bi-monthly digital magazine 

  • Full website access including our NOTB Guides 

  • Archive access to articles and premium content

  • Discounts to events and training

  • Subscriber only newsletter

£49.00
per year
SUBSCRIBE
Corporate
  • 3 print copies of bi-monthly magazine

  • Unlimited full website access for all your staff including the bi-monthly digital magazine and our NOTB guides 

  • Archive access to articles and premium content

  • Discounts to events and training

  • Exclusive members only deals, discounts and competitions

  • Subscriber only newsletter

£149.00
per year
SUBSCRIBE
Digital
  • Access to bi-monthly digital magazine 

  • Full website access including our NOTB Guides 

  • Archive access to articles and premium content

  • Discounts to events and training

  • Subscriber only newsletter

£24.99
per year
SUBSCRIBE
Join our mailing list
FREE NOTB email
Get our bi-weekly email packed with the latest articles and events straight to your inbox.

© 2025 News On The Block. All rights reserved.

News on the Block is a trading name of Premier Property Media Ltd.

We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By using our site you consent cookies.