
Could recurring water leaks and unexplained odour transfer between flats be revealing more about a building's fire compartmentation than the property management industry realises?
For many years, water leaks between flats have been treated primarily as plumbing and maintenance problems. A resident reports water coming through their ceiling, the managing agent contacts a plumber, the source is investigated, repairs are arranged and the resulting damage is reinstated.
The process is familiar to anyone involved in residential block management.
But perhaps there is another question worth asking: what if the route taken by the water is telling us something about the building's fire safety?
Having spent many years investigating fire compartmentation issues in blocks of flats, I believe there is a relationship that deserves greater attention. The connection between water travelling between properties, unexplained odour transfer and potentially defective fire compartmentation is an area that should prompt further investigation.
This is not to suggest that every water leak indicates defective fire stopping. Rather, it is about recognising that certain maintenance symptoms may be providing valuable clues about concealed weaknesses within a building.
Water travelling vertically through residential buildings is hardly unusual, “water will always find a way!” (a wise plumber once lamented…). Leaks originating from bathrooms, kitchens, heating systems, drainage connections and water supply pipework can affect properties several floors below the original source.
Sometimes the route is relatively straightforward. On other occasions, water appears in a completely different location from where the leak originated, leaving contractors and managing agents scratching their heads as to how it travelled there.
Service risers, pipe penetrations, concealed voids and openings around building services can all form part of these investigations.
From a maintenance perspective, the priority is understandably to identify the source, stop the leak and repair the damage.
However, from a fire safety standpoint, these same locations deserve attention for another reason.
A pipe passing through a fire-resisting floor or wall creates an opening that must be appropriately protected to maintain the required fire resistance. Where the opening has not been adequately sealed, or where existing fire stopping has been damaged or disturbed, it may provide a route for fire and smoke to spread.
The Home Office's guidance on fire safety in small blocks of flats specifically highlights the importance of protecting service penetrations and identifies service risers as locations where inadequate fire stopping is commonly found (Home Office, 2025).
The question, therefore, is not simply where the water has travelled, but what the route might reveal about the integrity of the surrounding construction.
This subject becomes even more interesting when considering guidance published by Cheshire Fire and Rescue Service.
Under its guidance on active and passive fire protection, the service identifies several possible signs of incomplete compartmentation.
Among them are:
A particularly strong smell coming from a neighbouring property or another storey, either above or below.
Having experienced a leak in a property from a storey or premises above.
(Cheshire Fire & Rescue Service, 2026).
This is particularly significant because it brings together two issues that are usually dealt with separately by property management teams.
Odour transfer is often treated as a ventilation problem, a nuisance complaint or an issue between neighbours. Water ingress is generally categorised as a plumbing or building maintenance problem.
Yet both are identified by the fire service as possible signs of incomplete compartmentation.
This does not establish that either symptom is necessarily caused by defective fire stopping. There may be other explanations, including plumbing defects, ventilation installations and air-pressure differences.
Nevertheless, it raises an important question: are we recognising the potential fire safety implications of these complaints early enough?
One particularly interesting aspect of odour transfer is that it may provide an earlier indication of a concealed pathway between properties.
Residents sometimes report strong cooking smells, cigarette smoke or other persistent odours entering their flats from neighbouring properties, particularly those directly above or below.
It is easy to dismiss these reports as everyday residential issues.
However, if air and odours are travelling between properties through unintended openings, there may be a wider building-integrity issue worth investigating.
Potential routes include gaps around pipework, electrical penetrations, service risers and concealed voids.
From a professional perspective, I believe unexplained odour transfer deserves greater attention, particularly when it occurs repeatedly between vertically adjoining properties.
Could it be indicating an opening in a compartment boundary that would also provide a potential route for smoke?
It is a question worth asking, rather than automatically treating the complaint as a ventilation or neighbour-related issue.
There is another observation from practical experience that raises an interesting question.
I have encountered situations where substantial quantities of water have accumulated within a flat and, rather than immediately appearing in the property below, have remained within the originating flat until eventually escaping through the entrance door.
At first glance, this might appear to demonstrate particularly effective compartmentation.
However, water containment and fire compartmentation are not the same thing. The ability of a floor to retain water depends on its construction, finishes, waterproofing, thresholds and other physical characteristics. It does not automatically demonstrate that the floor has adequate fire resistance or that service penetrations are correctly protected.
Nevertheless, these observations raise a worthwhile question about how buildings are understood and investigated.
If water is contained within a flat, what construction features are responsible? Are the same areas being maintained and protected for their fire-resisting function? And, where water does travel between properties, have the routes been investigated beyond the immediate plumbing defect?
The intention is not to use water movement as a test of compartmentation, but to consider whether it can provide an additional reason to investigate the building's concealed construction.
This is where the subject becomes particularly relevant to managing agents and those responsible for the day-to-day management of residential blocks, including RMCs and RTMs.
Managing agents are often the first point of contact when residents report leaks, unexplained smells, recurring dampness or unusual movement of air between properties.
They may not be responsible for undertaking specialist fire compartmentation inspections, but they are frequently in the best position to recognise recurring patterns and ensure that appropriate investigations take place.
The opportunity is to stop treating every incident as an isolated maintenance event.
For example:
Record recurring incidents. Identify repeated leaks, particularly those affecting vertically adjoining flats or involving service risers and concealed pipework.
Investigate unexplained odour transfer. Consider whether there may be an unintended pathway between properties rather than automatically categorising the complaint as a ventilation or nuisance issue.
Question previous works. Establish whether plumbing, electrical, refurbishment or other installation works may have disturbed existing fire stopping.
Consider the fire safety implications. Where investigations identify openings, damaged seals or unexplained pathways through compartment boundaries, obtain advice from a suitably competent passive fire protection specialist.
Maintain an evidence trail. Record defects, investigations, remedial works and supporting evidence so that recurring problems can be recognised and followed through.
This is not about turning every plumbing complaint into a fire safety investigation. It is about recognising when the circumstances justify looking beyond the immediate maintenance problem.
Any remedial fire stopping must be appropriate to the particular penetration, supporting construction and required fire resistance. Generic fillers or ordinary expanding foam should never be treated as substitutes for suitable fire-stopping systems.
The property management industry has become increasingly aware of the importance of fire compartmentation. However, fire safety management and routine maintenance are still frequently approached as separate disciplines.
A plumbing contractor investigates a leak. A ventilation contractor investigates an odour complaint. A fire safety specialist undertakes a compartmentation survey.
Each may be doing their job correctly, but information gathered through one investigation could be valuable to another.
The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) has also highlighted the prevalence of fire-stopping defects in existing UK buildings, including problems arising from poor design coordination, installation practices and inadequate treatment of service penetrations (Watkins, 2026).
Buildings change throughout their lifetime. Services are installed, replaced, removed and altered. Every intervention has the potential to affect previously protected openings if the work is not properly managed and reinstated.
Perhaps the opportunity is to connect these activities more effectively.
A recurring leak might reveal a concealed service route. An unexplained smell might indicate an unintended pathway between properties. Previous maintenance records might identify repeated disturbance to the same area of construction.
Individually, these observations may appear insignificant. Together, they could provide a reason to investigate whether the building's compartmentation remains intact.
Perhaps we should stop looking at water leaks purely as plumbing problems and start asking what else they might be telling us about the buildings we manage.
After all, the question is not simply where the water went.
It is what allowed it to get there.
Mihai Lamba, CIWFM, MIIRSM, TechIOSH, NEBOSH, Head of Estate Management, Bespoke Property Management (BPM)
References
Cheshire Fire & Rescue Service (2026) Active and passive fire protection. Updated 15 October 2026. Available at: https://www.cheshirefire.gov.uk/fire-protection/business-owner-landlord-or-employee/active-and-passive-fire-protection/
Home Office (2025) A guide to making your small block of flats safe from fire. Updated 20 January 2025. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/making-your-small-block-of-flats-safe-from-fire
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (2026) Fire safety: Approved Document B. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/fire-safety-approved-document-b
Watkins, C. (2026) 'Why are firestopping defects so common in existing buildings?', RICS Built Environment Journal, 8 April. Available at: https://ww3.rics.org/uk/en/journals/built-environment-journal/common-firestopping-defects.html
© 2026 News On The Block. All rights reserved.
News on the Block is a trading name of Premier Property Media Ltd.