Case Law

We provide summaries and analysis of important landmark legal decisions from the LVT, First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) and Higher Courts affecting the residential leasehold property sector. It is a valuable resource for anyone involved in this industry.
Search Case Law Listings

Assethold Limited v Watts

Right to Manage
The landlord’s legal costs incurred in party wall proceedings were not recoverable under the provision to “maintain or repair” but part of the costs (for taking professional advice prior to deciding what course to take and the cost of obtaining an injunction) were recoverable as the cost of “all works installations acts matters and things as in the reasonable discretion of the Landlord may be considered necessary or desirable for the proper maintenance safety amenity and administration of the Development". 

Francis v Philips

Right to Manage
The correct approach to the meaning of “qualifying works” in s.20 and s.20ZA of the 1985 Act is to identify whether works are parts of a set of works.

Westbrook Dolphin Square Limited v Friends Life Limited & Anr

Enfranchisement
A scheme set up with the sole purpose of taking advantage of the right to collective enfranchisement under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993 (“the Act”) by demising two leases each to hundreds of SPVs, in order to avoid the rule that a tenant holding three or more leases could not be a qualifying tenant under s.5, was effective.

Mount Eden Land Ltd v Bolsover Investments Ltd

Enfranchisement
Fear of a speculative enfranchisement was not a reasonable basis for a landlord withholding consent to alterations to a block to convert it into residential flats, on the particular facts of the case.

Clarise Properties Ltd v Rees

Enfranchisement
Valuation under the 1967 Act is difficult both in principle and in practice.

Kosta v the Trustees of the Phillimore Estate

Enfranchisement
A mathematical challenge to the RICS report graphs of relativity is unsuccessful.

Tibber v Buckely & Anr

Enfranchisement
A freeholder cannot seek a leaseback with a greater demise than that specified in the counter-notice.

Howard de Walden Estates Ltd v Accordway Ltd & Anr

Enfranchisement
Service of a notice of separate representation by an intermediate landlord under para 7 of Schedule 11 of the 1993 Act does not prevent the competent landlord agreeing the premium and terms of a lease extension so as to bind him. 

Nogueira v Westminster City Council

Service Charge
The First-tier Tribunal could not accept undertakings from a landlord to carry out remedial works as opposed to making a finding that the works were not of a reasonable standard.

One Housing Group v Kingham

Service Charge
The appellant was the landlord of a large residential estate in London, known as the Barkantine Estate. The estate had been constructed by Tower Hamlets LBC.

Southwark LBC v Oyeyinka

Service Charge
The appellant was the landlord of a house comprised two flats. The respondent was the tenant of one of the flats. The landlord served a notice, under the Service Charges (Consultation Requirements) (England) Regulations 2003 (SI 2003/1987), of intention to carry out works.

Barratt v Robinson

Service Charge
A landlord was not entitled to recover its legal costs under the covenant for reimbursement of costs in contemplation of proceedings under s.146 of the 1925 Act as there was no evidence that the landlord contemplated proceedings for forfeiture and, in any event, the amount claimed was below the prescribed sum.

Report a Case

Do you have a previously unreported case you would like to share on an anonymised basis? Want to suggest improvements? Please let us know by emailing enquiries@newsontheblock.com.

Case Law Editorial Team

Jonathan Upton
Managing Editor
Barrister, Serle Court
Justin Bates KC
Associate Editor
Barrister, Landmark Chambers

© 2025 News On The Block. All rights reserved.

News on the Block is a trading name of Premier Property Media Ltd.

We use cookies to improve your experience on our site. By using our site you consent cookies.